Friday, March 20, 2015

Sometimes the Internal Editor has a Point



“Rewrite it!” the brow-beating editor in my head demanded.
I balked and argued, “It’s OK as it is.”
“You’re in denial,” the same angry voice retorted, as it does every time we have an argument over my creativity.
My shoulders sagged. I didn’t want to hear this. When I’d sent the 7th draft of the second novel in my “Sacred Bundle Series” to three readers, I had held full confidence that this was it. I had crossed all my T’s and dotted all my I’s. However, the precious sentences had fallen short of their mark.
“I didn’t care about the characters or the story until page 56, and then I was hooked. If I didn’t know you and like you, I would never have continued reading the story.”
I certainly did not care for that critique. I wondered how on earth had this book gotten through two other reading panels without anyone telling me it was boring? Or that they didn’t understand the first page. THE FIRST PAGE, for God’s sake. I had to face the fact something was wrong, but I had no idea two weeks ago what it was.
The first draft of the The Spirit Bundle(TSB)has been finished since 2007. Between working on the nine drafts of The Marriage Bundle (TMB), I have been crafting the second one. But, a lot has happened since then. I have to admit I pushed the publishing of TMB. That story had needed more work, but I wanted something of my own creativity out in the world right after my husband passed away.
Now I was facing a huge dilemma. Did I ignore the suggestions of three well-meaning friends who had labored for a month or more over the second creation? So I took it to one other person, just one page, the first one, and asked him what he thought. He didn’t pull any punches either, but he had a few specific suggestions. Then I saw it.
I was writing with my head. The work was fashioned from a formula and the expressions were trite. I wondered, “When had my writing voice changed?”
Reviewing the events of my life, I remembered what had been happening since 2007 when I’d finished that first draft. Many changes. Many losses. Too many to keep my heart open and survive the pain of losing all those I loved, losing the community to which my husband and I had belonged. I’d been guided to sell my hand-built home on 40 acres and, after 33 years of living off the grid and in the woods,  I tried to survive in someone’s back bedroom for a year.
Now I am settled in my own little bungalow and living a life where I am expanding my social circle and embracing meaningful work.
During the week of all these questions, I attended several local events which added to the pressure of rethinking how I was approaching my writing, as well as my life.
I saw “Etty”, a one woman, one act play, presenting the journal writings of a 27 year-old Jewess who lived in Amsterdam between 1939 and 1941. This is before she is transported by cattle car to Auschwitz. Despite the terror and anger, she holds forth with love for those who are destroying her way of life. I cried that night for many reasons.
The next evening I sat with six other women around a circle of six men who were willing to voice their concerns and challenges about growing older and old. It was a circle of intimacy that broke down another door to my feelings and offered me a way to view people with a different level of compassion. I spent another night of tears.
Then there was the foot-stomping joy of the Celtic band where I felt so much a part of the Willits community.  On Saturday, I experienced the profound entertainment and increased understanding brought by watching the Museum Road Show.  This event chronicled the writings and stories of individuals who had helped to develop Mendocino County. There were stories from an older local Native man through the eyes of his granddaughter, a woman setting off from Iowa with their loaded wagon train plus livestock. She and her family arrived in Potter Valley with only the clothes on their backs. The story of Black Bart came alive in song and dance. The actors showed how the Civil War had been fought here in California. There was so much more in those stories of that evening’s entertainment. Everything I experienced that week was filled with authenticity and feeling.
Somewhere in the middle of all these shows, I found the courage to look at my own work again. Without the blinders on, I saw where I had forgotten to give my main characters their hearts.
I rewrote the first page and handed it to my harshest critic. He read it and grinned from ear to ear. “You nailed it. You hooked me.”
           Now I can do the eighth edit of The Spirit Bundle with much more confidence and enthusiasm. Now I feel my heart is back on line.